The four pearl types, side by side
Saltwater types are named for where they are farmed. Nearly all freshwater pearls on the market come from China. Nearly every pearl sold today is cultured; natural pearls are rare.
| Type | Oyster | Known for | Strand price, retail |
| Akoya | Pinctada fucata martensii, the Akoya oyster | The first pearl cultured commercially. Smaller, classically round, white and metallic shades. | $300 to $10,000 and above |
| South Sea | Pinctada maxima | Size, and exceptional golden color. | $1,000 to $100,000 and above |
| Tahitian | Pinctada margaritifera, the black lipped oyster | Exotic dark colors, and baroque shapes. | $500 to $25,000 and above |
| Freshwater | Freshwater mollusk, which can carry up to about 50 pearls at once | A vast range of shapes, sizes and colors. Round ones look almost identical to Akoya at a lower price. | $50 to $2,000 |
Saltwater pearls grow around a bead for roughly ten months to two years, with only one or two pearls per oyster at a time. That time, and so few pearls per oyster, is why they cost more.
The Tahitian nacre rule you have probably read is out of date. From 1998, French Polynesia required every exported Tahitian pearl to be X rayed and certified to at least 0.8mm of nacre per side, over 80 percent of the surface, and pearls that failed were destroyed. That requirement was scrapped in January 2017. All pearls may now be exported and are taxed regardless of quality, which is why few poor ones travel. Most pearl sites still print the rule as though it were current. It is worth knowing as a durability benchmark, roughly 1.0mm being a healthy depth, and not as a guarantee that anything on the market has passed a test.
Surface characteristics, and the three that are not flaws
Anything with organic origins carries imperfection. Most surface marks are cosmetic and lower the grade. Some are growth characteristics that do not, and one of them is evidence of quality.
| Characteristic | What it is | Lowers the grade |
| Wrinkles | Uneven nacre formation. Expected, and often desirable, on pearls nucleated to be non round. | Yes, on round pearls |
| Spots | Slight variations of color. | Yes |
| Abrasions | Scratches or scuffs that interrupt the luster. | Yes |
| Dents and divots | Indentations in the nacre, varying in size. | Yes |
| Mottling | A light plating pattern formed inside the oyster. | No. It indicates a thick nacre layer. |
| Kobs and tips | Growth characteristics. | No, unless chipped, which affects durability. |
| Circles | A growth characteristic that gives a distinctive banded look. | No. |
How rare a fine pearl actually is
| Stage | Share |
| Nucleated oysters that survive to bear a pearl | About 50 percent |
| Of those, pearls that are marketable | About 20 percent |
| Nucleated oysters yielding fine gem quality | Fewer than 5 percent |
| The grade above AAA | Hanadama, certified by the Pearl Science Laboratory in Tokyo |
These are figures the trade repeats rather than peer reviewed research, and pearl grading itself is not standardized, so treat every tier on every chart as one seller's opinion until you have looked at the pearl.
From the bench · Andrea Li
What a strand costs before it reaches a store
Every pearl chart online is written from the selling side. This is the buying side, from the trays at the Tucson gem shows.
| Where I was buying | Price per strand |
| Lower tier shows, early on | Under $20, freshwater |
| Gated shows, as my eye improved | Roughly $100 to $600 |
| My vendor now, at the AGTA show | Low hundreds into the low thousands |
Ranges, not invoices. The point is the distance between the tiers, which is close to two orders of magnitude for something a chart would call the same product.
Where I stop matters as much as where I start, and the metal is what decides it. My work is demi fine: sterling silver, gold filled, gold vermeil, and solid 14k gold on occasion. Fine jewelry is solid 18k or 24k gold and platinum, and those metals are what carry a very expensive stone. A single pearl at several hundred to several thousand dollars belongs in a setting built to hold it for a lifetime, which is a different piece from the one I am making. So my ceiling is deliberate, not a budget. Grading charts show you every tier as though a buyer should climb to the top of it, and none of them tells you which tier suits the work in front of you.
Pearls are sold in bundles the trade calls bead lots. I have always called them shanks. A shank holds roughly 25 to 50 strands of small 2mm pearls, or around 15 strands at 10 to 11mm. I go through every strand in a shank before I choose one, looking for brilliance of luster, uniform shape, and consistent iridescence. What I will not buy is thin nacre: chalky patches, dull spots, irregular shapes and sizes.
The shows run in tiers, and the tier tells you what you are looking at. At the open end, vendors convert motel rooms into showrooms, free and no registration. Above that, tented shows you register for. At the top, the AGTA GemFair, indoors at the Tucson Convention Center. AGTA vets its buyers as well as its vendors: to get in I had to produce receipts proving my business had spent at least $10,000 in the previous year, along with my business license, cards and packaging. Once quality has been filtered that far upstream, the only thing left deciding what reaches my tray is taste.
One thing no chart will tell you. Pearls are less brittle than gemstones when you drill them, and more fragile than gemstones once they are set. A pearl is aragonite platelets bound by conchiolin, built like structural plywood rather than a rigid crystal, so a bit passes through without the stress that chips a briolette at its narrowest point. That same softness is why a finished pearl needs protecting in a way a sapphire never does.